steeleye span tour
steeleye span tour

Newsletter

IN THE ROOTS OF MUSIC

IN THE ROOTS OF MUSIC

spiral earth
music festival directory

Rock ‘N’ Roll Survivors & Rock ‘N’ Roll Survivors Live Opera 1974 – Fanny.

Sep 19, 2025

Spiral Earth rating

“One of the most important female bands in American rock has been buried without a trace. Fanny were one of the finest rock bands of their time. They were extraordinary.” So said David Bowie back in 1973. Yet despite widespread critical acclaim by the end of that year the band were frustrated by their lack of success and were broke.

Signed to Warner Bros despite two Top 40 hits in the US and the assistance of two major league producers in Richard Perry and Todd Rundgren the original quartet didn’t translate that into album sales. In a bid to make them more marketable their label wanted to change the image of the band into a glam hard rock style but this was resisted and led to them being dropped.

Guitarist June Millington and drummer Alice de Buhr left at this point but June’s sister bassist Jean Millington and Nickey Barclay on keyboards decided to soldier on. Recruiting Suzi Quatro’s sister Patti on guitar and Brie Brandt on drums the band signed to the newly formed Casablanca imprint. Signing to a label that featured glam rockers Kiss it was no surprise that Fanny re-emerged with the kind of look Warners had wanted – all mascara and poodle perms!

It’s hard to make a proper assessment of the album due to the slick production by Vini Poncia whose talents were more suited to other genres. The title cut that opens the album is a case in point with the guitars so low in the mix it effectively neuters what could have been a statement of intent for the new line-up saying “We’re Back!”

Lame production apart though, to be fair to their producer there was a definite lack of direction  at this point. The Joie De Vivre and straight forward approach that was part of the original band is patently missing to be replaced by rockers like ‘Rockin’ All Night Long’ and ‘Got Out Of The Jungle’ or cover versions of late fifties and early sixties pop like ‘Sally Goes Round The Roses’  – I kid you not. All a long way from the original band’s masterful interpretations of the Beatles’ ‘Hey Bulldog’ or Cream’s  ‘Badge.’ 

All this means that there is a palpable air of uncertainty surrounding this album. For all that being said the band did muster a hit single from the wreckage with the pop-tastic  ‘Butter Boy’. Starting off with a doo-wop style intro, this R’n’B flavoured tune was a controversial number born out of Jean Millington’s fling with David Bowie and containing the couplet, “He was hard as a rock, but I was ready to roll ” Banned by the BBC of course.

Remastered for this issue the package also contains bonus tracks from the new line- ups first ever gig recorded on Xmas Eve 1974 at the famous Whisky A Go Go. Also included are live recordings from the proposed ‘Rock’n’Roll Survivors Rock Opera,’ released here for the first time. Don’t expect soundboard quality though, these are lower-fi  recordings taped on a cassette. For the die-hards it is a purchase and worth careful exploration by the rest. Though whether some tracks would be politically correct today is a point for discussion.

Lyndon Noon.

www.cherryred.co.uk

Share This:

siobhan miller band at kings place

Recent Posts

Only Dogs As Friends – Bird In The Belly.

Only Dogs As Friends - Bird In The Belly.

Curious and curiouser. I mean why'd you cover your head with sack cloth and wear a trilby? What's with a collection of heads? All these are questions that an immediate scan of the album cover alone raises. Other questions are available and you can...

Read More
Two Gentlemen. Donal Lunny & Keith Christmas.

Two Gentlemen. Donal Lunny & Keith Christmas.

October robbed the folk scene of two long standing, contrasting musicians, Donal Lunny & Keith Christmas. Here Simon Jones recalls their careers and pays tribute to each. Donal Lunny (above) who passed away on October the 23rd was undoubtedly a...

Read More
Sing the World Awake – Baka Beyond.

Sing the World Awake - Baka Beyond.

At the heart of Baka Beyond are guitarist Martin Cradick and Vocalist Su Hart along with their three-decade relationship with the Baka people of the Cameroonian rain forest.  What emerges is a musical synthesis, incorporating, not just the in-situ...

Read More
Thirty Six Years Of Croftwork.

Thirty Six Years Of Croftwork.

With a musical appreciation fuelled by wanderlust and desire to fuse Highland Scots music with ever widening and progressive influences Shooglenifty have been regularly journeying off map for three and a half decades, winning new friends and...

Read More

Follow Us:

Related Posts

Only Dogs As Friends – Bird In The Belly.

Only Dogs As Friends - Bird In The Belly.

Curious and curiouser. I mean why'd you cover your head with sack cloth and wear a trilby? What's with a collection of heads? All these are questions that an immediate scan of the album cover alone raises. Other questions are available and you can...

Read More
Live In London. Camden Palace 1984 – John Martyn.

Live In London. Camden Palace 1984 - John Martyn.

From Martyn's suits'n'synths period 1984, recently returned to Island records who believed they could mould their errant son into a celtic soul jazz brother, in the manner of Van Morrison, John as usual had other ideas. The album which this live...

Read More
Two Gentlemen. Donal Lunny & Keith Christmas.

Two Gentlemen. Donal Lunny & Keith Christmas.

October robbed the folk scene of two long standing, contrasting musicians, Donal Lunny & Keith Christmas. Here Simon Jones recalls their careers and pays tribute to each. Donal Lunny (above) who passed away on October the 23rd was undoubtedly a...

Read More